(Bloomberg) — Greenwashing may be the biggest risk to the future of ESG investing, but there’s no firm agreement on what it means in a legal or regulatory context.The term has become ubiquitous with the rise of ESG. It’s typically used when companies, people or governments overstate, misrepresent or just plain lie about their climate credentials.For example, a company says it’s reducing its carbon footprint—but fails to say that the calculation excludes massive emissions produced by its customers or suppliers. Or an asset manager overhypes the environmental, social and governance standards it uses to allocate clients’ money. But know-it-when-you-see-it doesn’t translate well into statutory authority.
Most Read from Bloomberg
US Safety Agency to Consider Ban on Gas Stoves Amid Health Fears
Universal Plans New Family Resort in Texas, Las Vegas Horror Attraction
US Flights Latest: Departures Resume After FAA Lifts Ground Stop
Rental Housing Is Suddenly Headed Toward a Hard Landing
Mexican President’s 28-Minute Monologue Had Biden, Trudeau Staring at Feet
“The battle to stamp out greenwashing continues to be foiled by the lack of a clear and common definition across jurisdictions,” said Maia Godemer, a London-based sustainable finance analyst at BloombergNEF. “The market can only continue to flourish if regulators build a common framework around what is considered environmentally or socially sustainable.”
Policymakers in Europe have been the most aggressive in trying to flesh out such a framework, but complications continue to emerge.
The European Securities and Markets Authority lists tackling greenwashing among its top priorities. But the markets watchdog struggles to specifically describe what it is.
In November, ESMA along with the European Banking Authority and the European Insurance and Occupational Pensions Authority launched a joint review to gauge the scale of exaggerated ESG investing statements. It’s part of an effort to evaluate how well existing regulations are working, and “to gather useful and concrete examples that will help the ESAs to better understand greenwashing,” according to the document.
The results of the European regulatory effort have been dramatic. Many asset managers have been forced to stop claiming levels of sustainability in their investments that don’t meet the standard under the new rules.
But the lack of conformity among agencies and jurisdictions is “leading to misinterpretation and inconsistent application of the rules,” Godemer said. Unless there’s more clarity and consistency, she said it’s likely investors will simply pare back their holdings of funds advertised as sustainable.
The European Union’s Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation may arguably be a prime example. Instead of providing a uniform interpretation of what’s an ESG fund and what’s not, it’s prompted concern that investors have put their money in funds marketed as pure-play ESG products when they aren’t.
During the second half of last year, financial giants including BlackRock Inc., Amundi SA, Axa Investment Managers and the investment arm of Banque Pictet & Cie SA stopped claiming that $140 billion worth of their funds actually qualified for the EU’s top ESG designation, known as Article 9.
Why? Because the EU clarified its definition of Article 9 funds, saying the labeling must be reserved, with few exceptions, for 100% sustainable investments.
Read More: Pictet Says $14 Billion of Funds to Lose Top ESG Designation
Now there are calls for the European Commission and ESMA to ensure transparency by financial firms when they are forced to reclassify funds. Retail clients fearful of being exposed to greenwashing have started pointing fingers at those firms, accusing them of keeping the flow of information on ESG downgrades to a minimum.
And it’s not just the fund industry where company confusion and investor anger is rising. The fast-growing market for sustainability-linked bonds also has been tainted.
“Financial market participants also need to ramp up their knowledge and educate themselves,” Godemer said. Countries “will never completely agree on fully aligning their standards,” but regulators should at least develop an international structure that covers “the baseline of sustainability reporting.”
If they don’t, she warns, the result will be more greenwashing-related litigation.
Bloomberg Green publishes Good Business every week, providing unique insights on ESG and climate-conscious investing.
Most Read from Bloomberg Businessweek
America’s Aggressive Chip Strategy Forces China Into a Corner
Used-Car Prices Are Finally Dropping
After the GOP’s Strife, the Big Winner Might Be Joe Biden
The Great American EV Battery Revolution Might Finally Be Here
Poland’s Election Provides a Path Out of EU Isolation
©2023 Bloomberg L.P.
Shares of semiconductor stocks Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing (NYSE: TSM), Nvidia (NASDAQ: NVDA), and Skyworks Solutions (NASDAQ: SWKS) were rising on Tuesday, up as much as 3.4%, 4.6%, and 2.2%, before settling into gains of 2.7%, 4%, and 0.6%, respectively, as of 1:42 p.m. ET. The sector-wide optimism was helped along by a positive note from Bank of America semiconductor analyst Vivek Arya this morning, along with continued optimism over moderating inflation and the broader economy. Arya wrote, "We assume a soft-landing (nonmemory semi sales down [less than 5% year over year], also confirmed by recent Taiwan Semiconductor (TSM) results/outlook) as consumer chip inventory correction is completed by [the first half] and as industrial/auto chip pricing remains resilient."
Question: Two years ago my husband took an early retirement when offered by his company. At that time we had a 401(k) with about $550,000 that we gave to a big financial services firm rep to handle. Answer: There are a few questions to ask here: First, is your withdrawal rate reasonable; second did your adviser do you wrong with those big losses; and third, what do you do about the adviser situation?
On a generally down Tuesday for the stock market, Verizon Communications' (NYSE: VZ) shares did worse than those of many other companies. The telecom giant saw its stock price erode by nearly 2.5%, amid a general slump in tech stocks and related titles, combined with a discouraging price cut from a prominent bank. Before market open, analyst Bryan Craft of Deutsche Bank enacted a 10% cut to his level on Verizon stock.
The bear market knocked down growth stocks by the dozens last year — even if these companies didn't report bad news. So, if a particular growth company actually did report disappointing news, losses were much greater.
Thanks to the moves of a pair of analysts, investors have taken more notice of the high-yielding REIT.
The conventional wisdom outlook for 2023 is mixed – most market watchers and economists would say that a recession is likely during the first half of the year, with disagreements centered more on the duration and depth of a downturn than its likelihood, and a rebound will come in the second half, leading to stock markets finishing this year about where they began. Weighing in from Morgan Stanley, chief Us equity strategist Mike Wilson notes the conventional wisdom, saying: “Both the sell and buy
The bank's profit plunged 66% in the fourth quarter, with high expenses and weak investment banking revenue.
These half-dozen stocks will account for the lion's share of Berkshire Hathaway's more than $6 billion in dividend income this year.
Today we will run through one way of estimating the intrinsic value of AMC Entertainment Holdings, Inc. ( NYSE:AMC ) by…
The major indexes were mixed on Tuesday, as the S&P 500 was down 8 points (0.2%), the Dow Jones Industrial Average was off 392 points (1.1%), while the Nasdaq Composite was down 16 points (0.14%). It is fourth-quarter earnings season, and the market took a bit of a hit today as some of the big bellwether banks reported Tuesday, including Goldman Sachs and Morgan Stanley. Goldman Sachs had its worst earnings miss in a decade, as it got hit hard by the slowdown in the investment banking business.
Stocks moving after hours on Jan. 17, 2023: United Airlines, Interactive Brokers, Moderna
A look at the shareholders of Plug Power Inc. ( NASDAQ:PLUG ) can tell us which group is most powerful. With 55% stake…
Collapsed crypto exchange FTX, which is currently in bankruptcy, says it has identified $5.5 billion of liquid assets but based on current estimates both the international and U.S. based exchange still have a "substantial shortfall" relative to what customers are owed.
Futures rose and yields fell as the Bank of Japan stayed dovish. The market rally paused while Tesla stock jumped. United Airlines, Moderna rose overnight. Microsoft job cuts loom.
Apple shares are mixed to start the holiday-shortened week. Coming into Tuesday, Apple stock had rallied in five of the previous six sessions, with the lone down day a loss of just 0.06%. Apple is one of the few megacap tech stocks that had avoided getting pummeled in 2022.
Devon Energy (NYSE: DVN) has become one of the more popular stocks in the oil patch over the past year. Thanks to its innovative fixed-plus-variable dividend framework, Devon paid over $5 per share in dividends last year, giving it a roughly 8% annualized yield on the recent stock price. Devon's pain could become Pioneer Natural Resources (NYSE: PXD) gain.
Being rich and being wealthy are often seen as being the same thing. After all, people who are rich or wealthy tend to have more assets and greater financial freedom than the typical person. In reality, there are some major … Continue reading → The post Key Differences Between Rich and Wealthy People appeared first on SmartAsset Blog.
Image source: The Motley Fool. New Oriental Education & Technology Group (NYSE: EDU)Q2 2023 Earnings CallJan 17, 2023, 8:00 a.m. ETContents: Prepared Remarks Questions and Answers Call Participants Prepared Remarks: OperatorGood evening, and thank you for standing by for New Oriental's fiscal year 2023 second-quarter results earnings conference call.
These high-octane income stocks, with yields ranging from 10% to 12.8%, can fatten your pocketbook in the new year.
Evercore ISI analyst Amit Daryanani added both Apple and IBM stock to a roster of names expected to be strong near-term performers.
What’s the Legal Definition of Greenwashing? – Yahoo Finance
